werbero.comThe magazine for advertising that works

Industries

Advertising for insurance brokers

Comparison sites took the simple products. What remains is complex advice, and that is a better business if the marketing says so.

Dec 4, 2025 2 min read 382 words
Advertising for insurance brokers

Key points

  • Do not compete with comparison sites on standard products; you will lose.
  • Complexity is the broker's market: business, specialist and combined risks.
  • Regulatory rules on financial promotions apply to everything you publish.

Comparison platforms have taken the standardised end of the insurance market. Competing there means bidding against companies with far larger budgets for customers who choose on price alone.

The remaining market is the better one

Where a comparison form cannot handle the risk, a broker is necessary: businesses with unusual exposures, high-value or listed property, professional indemnity, combined commercial policies, marine, agricultural, and anything where the wording matters.

Those clients are less price-sensitive, stay longer and generate advice fees as well as commission.

A comparison site sells a price. A broker sells the certainty that the claim will be paid. That difference is only worth something if it is explained.

Explain what a broker actually does

Most business owners do not know. They believe insurance is a commodity and that the broker is a middleman adding cost.

Content that changes that: worked examples of claims that were paid because the cover was correctly arranged and would not have been otherwise; explanation of exclusions that catch people out; the difference between similar-looking policies at different prices.

That is genuinely useful and almost nobody publishes it.

Segments worth owning

SegmentWhy
One trade or professionyou learn the risks, they refer each other
Businesses above a turnover thresholdcomplexity, retention
Landlords and property portfoliosrecurring, growing
Specialist and non-standard riskslittle competition
Professional indemnity by professionmandatory, renewable

Owning one trade produces referral within it, which is the cheapest acquisition available in this sector.

Renewal is the retention moment

Clients leave at renewal, usually because nobody contacted them. A structured renewal process, starting six weeks out with a review rather than an invoice, is the single largest retention lever.

It is also the moment additional cover is sold, because the client is thinking about the risk.

The regulatory frame

Financial promotions are regulated, and the rules cover clarity, fairness, balance and the presentation of risk. They typically apply to websites, social posts, emails and printed material alike.

Practical consequences: claims must be substantiated, benefits and limitations presented with equal prominence, and records of what was published kept. Approval processes exist for a reason and skipping them is where firms get into difficulty.

The referral network

Accountants, solicitors and commercial finance brokers meet businesses at the moment their insurance needs change. Those relationships produce better business than any advertising and are maintained by reciprocity and reliability.

Frequently asked questions

Can a broker win private motor and household business?

Rarely on price. Occasionally on service, or as part of a wider relationship. It is not a growth strategy.

Where is the growth?

Commercial lines, specialist risks, and clients whose circumstances do not fit a comparison form.

More from Industries

Keep reading

All articles
Advertising for trade businesses

Industries

Advertising for trade businesses

Most trade firms have too much work and too few staff. That inverts the entire advertising brief, and almost nobody adjusts for it.

2 min readMar 6, 2026
Advertising for roofing companies

Industries

Advertising for roofing companies

Roofing demand is weather-driven, seasonal, and half of it is an emergency. Three different campaigns, not one.

2 min readMar 4, 2026
Advertising for electrical contractors

Industries

Advertising for electrical contractors

Small callouts pay poorly and fill the diary. Advertising should be aimed at the three job types that actually carry the business.

2 min readMar 2, 2026